In everyday conversations, we often use the terms rights, responsibilities, and privileges interchangeably. But they aren’t the same—and when it comes to freedom of speech, knowing the difference matters.
Rights
A right is something inherent or protected by law. In the United States, freedom of speech is a constitutional right guaranteed under the First Amendment. This means that, generally, the government cannot punish you simply for expressing your opinion, no matter how unpopular it may be.
However, rights are not absolute. For example, speech that incites violence, threats, or defamation is not protected. Understanding these limits helps us see that rights exist within a legal framework.
Responsibilities
With every right comes responsibility. Freedom of speech gives us the ability to speak, but it does not shield us from the impact of what we say. Our words can influence others, build bridges, or cause harm.
Being responsible with speech means thinking about context, audience, and potential consequences. For example, shouting fire in a crowded theater when there is no fire isn’t just irresponsible—it’s dangerous. The responsibility attached to free speech requires us to balance expression with respect for safety, truth, and civility.
Privileges
Unlike rights, privileges are granted and can be taken away. Driving a car is a privilege, as is holding a professional license or working in certain jobs. Privileges often come with codes of conduct or standards that limit how speech can be expressed.
Freedom of Speech in Professions
Here’s where the balance between rights, responsibilities, and privileges becomes most visible. While individuals have the right to free speech, certain professions hold people to higher standards:
-
Teachers: A teacher in Pennsylvania was fired after posting derogatory comments about students on her blog. She had the right to post, but the district determined that her speech disrupted the classroom environment.
-
Doctors and Lawyers: Medical boards have disciplined doctors who spread misinformation about vaccines online, ruling that their speech violated professional ethics. Lawyers, too, can be sanctioned for public statements that undermine the integrity of the court.
-
Military or Law Enforcement: Several police officers across the U.S. have lost jobs or been suspended after making inflammatory or racist posts on Facebook. The courts have largely upheld these actions, stressing that maintaining public trust outweighs personal expression in such roles.
-
Public Service Workers (City, State, Municipal): A city employee in New Jersey lost his job after making offensive comments online about residents. The city argued that his statements damaged public confidence in government services, and courts agreed the discipline was lawful.
Working or Volunteering With Children
For those in positions of trust with children—such as coaches, youth leaders, or scout volunteers—speech is held to especially high standards. In one case, a youth football coach was removed after making vulgar and threatening remarks on social media. Even though he wasn’t speaking in his role as coach, his words conflicted with the privilege of mentoring kids and being seen as a role model.
The Social Media Factor
In the age of social media, the line between personal and professional speech is increasingly blurred. A private citizen may post an opinion online with few consequences. But for a teacher, police officer, coach, or public employee, the same post could be seen as damaging to their role or eroding trust in the institution they represent.
Courts have generally upheld that public employees do not lose their free speech rights, but their speech can be limited if it disrupts the workplace, harms the agency’s mission, or undermines public trust. In other words, your Facebook or Instagram post may be legal, but it may still carry professional consequences.
Conclusion
Freedom of speech is a right that allows us to express ourselves without government censorship. But it comes with responsibilities—our words carry weight and consequences. And in many cases, the privileges we hold in professional or societal roles require us to exercise that right carefully.
In short:
-
Rights protect your freedom.
-
Responsibilities guide how you use it.
-
Privileges remind you that not all contexts allow unlimited expression.
Understanding this balance not only deepens our respect for free speech but also helps us navigate its power wisely in a complex world—especially in roles that involve public trust, service, and the lives of children.
“Freedom of speech gives us a voice—how we use it defines who we are.”